349: How to Price a Listing

Is there a magical number when it comes to pricing a listing? No, not really. But there IS a way to walk into every listing appointment confident, prepared, and ready to have a real conversation about price with your sellers. In this episode, we are finally tackling the how-to of pricing a listing. We have touched on it before, but today we are getting into the actual nuts and bolts of how we prep, what we bring, what we say, and how we guide sellers through one of the most important (and emotional) parts of the listing process. We are sharing the exact questions we ask on that first call, how we prep our CMAs, the talking points we lean on every single time, and the framework that has never failed us: price, location, and condition. We also dig into the pricing pyramid, the buyer pool conversation, and why the data has to drive every decision, even when sellers want a number that the data just does not support. Here's what we cover in this episode: The questions we ask on the very first seller call How we prep before walking into a listing appointment Why we never give a price before we see the house in person How to use the CMA summary as a collaborative tool with sellers Why price per square foot is a guide, not a rule The three components of every listing: price, location, and condition The pricing pyramid and how it impacts your buyer pool What to say when sellers want a number the data does not support How to handle the "how did you come up with this price?" question Why pending and active listings matter as much as solds How to set up neighborhood searches to keep sellers engaged before they list How to talk about price reductions before they happen The detective work that sets you apart from every other agent Key Quotes & Takeaways: "I am a data driven person. I come from a family of appraisers. I want the numbers to fit in a box." Alissa "I do not want you doing showings for 90 days. I want you to do it right for two weeks or less." Katy "When I list your house and another agent calls me to ask how I came up with that price, I need to be able to support it with data." Alissa "If we have no showings, it is the price. If we have lots of showings but no offers, it is the condition." Katy "There is no magic number. You have to do the work, and you have to be ready to adjust." Alissa Products, People & Previous Episodes Mentioned: Episode 97: How to Do a CMA (hustlehumblypodcast.com) Episode 144: Numbers to Know (hustlehumblypodcast.com) Episode 321: Pre-Listing Appraisal: Helpful or Hindering? (hustlehumblypodcast.com) Seller Net Sheet + Buyer Cost Sheet (hustlehumblypodcast.com/netsheet) Agent Systems 101 Hustle Humbly Community Want to toast someone on the show? Send us a voice or video message with your name, who you're toasting, and why! Email it to team@hustlehumblypodcast.com. Leave us a review at

You can listen to 349: How to Price a Listing online on Radio and Podcast. Open the player on this page to stream the available audio.

349: How to Price a Listing is an episode from Hustle Humbly Podcast by Alissa Jenkins & Katy Caldwell.

This episode is 52:44 long.

This episode was published on Apr 13, 2026.

Yes. Use the heart button on the episode page to add it to your favorite episodes list.

Yes. This page shows related episodes from Hustle Humbly Podcast when more episodes are available from the podcast feed.