Episode 485: "Daddy Magic" Matt Menard

What Happened When by Podcast Heat

May 6, 202601:03:21Sports & Recreation

On this week's episode of What Happened When, Tony Schiavone and Conrad Thompson are joined by the ever-entertaining Matt Menard for a wild ride through one of All Elite Wrestling 's most chaotic matches ever. The trio f...

Related Episodes

Continue listening to more episodes from What Happened When.

Episode 503: Austin and Colten Gunn

Sep 9, 2026 - 01:25:04

On this special episode of What Happened When, Tony Schiavone and Conrad Thompson remember Andy "The Butc...

Episode 502: Tempers Rising

Sep 2, 2026 - 01:50:16

On this episode of What Happened When, Tony Schiavone and Conrad Thompson fire up the time machine and re...

Episode 501: Baby Doll Betrays Dusty!

Aug 26, 2026 - 01:27:11

On this episode of What Happened When, Tony Schiavone and Conrad Thompson fire up the time machine and he...

Episode 500: Rocky Romero

Aug 19, 2026 - 01:17:27

It's a milestone celebration 500 episodes in the making! On this special edition of What Happened When ,...

Episode 499: 30th anniversary of WCW Hog Wild

Aug 12, 2026 - 01:17:24

It's a wild one on What Happened When! Tony Schiavone and Conrad Thompson cover it all, starting with Ton...

Episode 498: Dusty Is Champ!

Aug 5, 2026 - 01:52:17

On this edition of What Happened When, Tony Schiavone and Conrad Thompson travel back 40 years to the fin...

Episode 497: Dr. Luther

Jul 29, 2026 - 01:24:38

Tony Schiavone has seen a lot in professional wrestling, but even he may not be prepared for this trip do...

Episode 496: RJ City Returns!

Jul 22, 2026 - 01:41:27

This week, Tony Schiavone and Conrad Thompson welcome AEW superstar, actor, writer, and independent wrest...