Episode 485: "Daddy Magic" Matt Menard

On this week's episode of What Happened When, Tony Schiavone and Conrad Thompson are joined by the ever-entertaining Matt Menard for a wild ride through one of All Elite Wrestling 's most chaotic matches ever. The trio fires up Double or Nothing 2022 and revisits the unforgettable "Anarchy in the Arena" match, a brutal, anything goes spectacle that redefined mayhem in AEW. From the nonstop brawling to the blood-soaked moments and absolute carnage, Matt gives firsthand insight into what it was like being part of the madness, while Tony shares his perspective from the commentary desk. BLUECHEW - Right now, when you buy two months of BlueChew Gold, you get the third for FREE with promo code WHW. Visit for more details and important safety information, and we thank BlueChew for sponsoring the podcast. MORGAN & MORGAN - If you're ever injured, you can check out Morgan & Morgan. Their fee is FREE unless they win. For more information go to ForThePeople.Com/WHW or dial (#529) from your cell phone. SAVE WITH CONRAD - Stop throwing money away by paying those high interest rates on your credit card. Roll them into one low monthly payment and on top of that, skip your next two house payments. Go to to learn more.

You can listen to Episode 485: "Daddy Magic" Matt Menard online on Radio and Podcast. Open the player on this page to stream the available audio.

Episode 485: "Daddy Magic" Matt Menard is an episode from What Happened When by Podcast Heat.

This episode is 01:03:21 long.

This episode was published on May 6, 2026.

Yes. Use the heart button on the episode page to add it to your favorite episodes list.

Yes. This page shows related episodes from What Happened When when more episodes are available from the podcast feed.