Ep. 81 She Left Her Car Running... Then Vanished The Paige Renkoski Case

Wednesday Night Mysteries by Weeknight Mysteries Podcast

Aug 12, 202692:15True Crime

On 24 May 1990, 30 year old substitute teacher Paige Renkoski disappeared after stopping on the shoulder of Interstate 96 near Fowlerville, Michigan. Witnesses reported seeing Paige talking with one or more men near a ma...

Related Episodes

Continue listening to more episodes from Wednesday Night Mysteries.

Ep. 85 She Was Supposed to Start a New Life... Then She Disappeared The Marion Barter Case

Sep 9, 2026 - 96:24

On 22 June 1997, 51 year old Marion Barter left Southport, Queensland, to begin a year-long trip through...

Ep. 84 She Vanished at 16... Then Her Name Kept Appearing The Samantha Tapp Case

Sep 2, 2026 - 92:34

On 12 October 2004, 16 year old Samantha Tapp disappeared from Burleson, Texas. After an argument with he...

Ep. 83 She Was Three Minutes From Home... Then She Vanished The Beverly Potts Case

Aug 26, 2026 - 105:20

On 24 August 1951, 10 year old Beverly Potts disappeared while walking home from a children's performance...

Ep. 82 Claudia Lawrence: The Cars, The CCTV & The Missing Answers

Aug 19, 2026 - 109:12

On 18 March 2009, 35 year old University of York chef Claudia Lawrence disappeared from her home in Hewor...

Ep. 80 What Happened to Patrick Carnes? The Interstate 80 Mystery

Aug 5, 2026 - 77:42

On 14 April 2011, 86 year old Patrick Carnes was driving home to Reno, Nevada after visiting family and t...

Ep. 79 She Left Work Sick... Then Disappeared The Andrea Allen Case

Jul 29, 2026 - 83:09

On 21 May 1982, 23 year old secretary Andrea Allen left work early in West Palm Beach, Florida after tell...

#78 What Happened to Gus Lamont? Australia's Outback Mystery

Jul 22, 2026 - 81:53

On 27 September 2025, 4 year old Gus Lamont disappeared from his family's remote sheep station, Oak Park...

#77 What Really Happened to Rey Rivera? The Belvedere Hotel Case

Jul 15, 2026 - 100:00

On 16 May 2006, 32 year old aspiring screenwriter Rey Rivera disappeared after receiving a phone call and...