Mormonism w/David Archuleta-PT1: "America's Mormon Idol"

David Archuleta was seventeen years old, Mormon to his core, and singing in front of thirty million people on American Idol. America saw the golden boy - the angel voice, the humble smile, the kid who made grown adults cry on national television. What they didn't see was the father who controlled every note, every decision, every version of David he was allowed to be. "I basically was his puppet." Behind the fame was the sweetest kid grappling with his own sexuality because his church told him who he was allowed to love, and who he wanted to love wasn't on their yes list. David believed that if he just prayed hard enough, God would "fix" the one thing about himself he'd been taught to hate. Spoiler: God had other plans. Today is Part 1 of his story... it wrecked us in the best way. Part 2 is available NOW exclusively for PATREON members . DAVID'S NEW MEMOIR DEVOUT is now available.

You can listen to Mormonism w/David Archuleta-PT1: "America's Mormon Idol" online on Radio and Podcast. Open the player on this page to stream the available audio.

Mormonism w/David Archuleta-PT1: "America's Mormon Idol" is an episode from Was I In A Cult? by PodcastOne.

This episode is 01:04:48 long.

This episode was published on Feb 17, 2026.

Yes. Use the heart button on the episode page to add it to your favorite episodes list.

Yes. This page shows related episodes from Was I In A Cult? when more episodes are available from the podcast feed.