Cavin' around: Sybil's Cave & The Murder of Mary Rogers, Dungeon Rock & Ghost Treasure, plus Hellhole Cave & Batboy

Join us as we go spelunking! We'll explore three caves (Sybil's Cave in Hoboken, New Jersey, Dungeon Rock in Lynn, Massachusetts, and Hellhole Cave in West Virginia) and the spooky stories that go along with each one. We'll discuss a 19th century murder that may have inspired Edgar Allan Poe, a man who spent decades digging into a rock on the advice of a ghost pirate, and the legendary Bat Boy. Plus, Amanda has a tiny little cave story. Join our Reddit community: Join our Facebook group here: A special thank you to our jam thief, Mary Quiton! Have an episode idea or a question about a case? Submit them here: Twitter @truecreeps Instagram @truecreepspod Facebook.com/truecreepspod Email us at truecreepspod@gmail.com The Tragic Tale of Mary Rogers and Sybil’s Cave WV Underground - Highland Outdoors The Labyrinth Below – Wonderful West Virginia Magazine Dungeon Rock in Lynn | Atlas Obscura Dungeon Rock and The New England Frankenstein | Obscure Vermont Dungeon Rock, Lynn Woods · Swampscott Public Library, Swampscott, Mass. · NOBLE Digital Heritage Hiram Marble, Eccentric Treasure Hunter (part 1) The Pledge of Allegiance Debuts in a Boston Magazine The Pirate Ghost of Dungeon Rock - Salem Ghosts Dungeon Rock in Lynn, Massachusetts started with a pirate ghost and a treasure hunt - CBS Boston The history and mysteries of Lynn’s ‘haunted’ pirate cave | GBH The Mysterious Murder of the Beautiful Cigar Girl - Atlas Obscura Sybil's Cave in Hoboken | Atlas Obscura Weekly World News - Google Books Weekly World News - Google Books Weekly World News - Google Books Weekly World News - Google Books Weekly World News - Google Books Weekly World News - Google Books Weekly World News - Google Books Weekly World News - Google Books Weekly World News - Google Books Weekly World News - Google Books Weekly World News - Google Books Weekly World News - Google Books Weekly World News - Google Books Weekly World News - Google Books Weekly World News - Google Books Weekly World News - Google Books Weekly World News - Google Books Weekly World News - Google Books Weekly World News - Google Books Weekly World News - Google Books Weekly World News - Google Books Bat Boy Found in West Virginia Cave 30 Years Ago!! - Weekly World News This podcast uses the following third-party services for analysis: Spotify Ad Analytics -

You can listen to Cavin' around: Sybil's Cave & The Murder of Mary Rogers, Dungeon Rock & Ghost Treasure, plus Hellhole Cave & Batboy online on Radio and Podcast. Open the player on this page to stream the available audio.

Cavin' around: Sybil's Cave & The Murder of Mary Rogers, Dungeon Rock & Ghost Treasure, plus Hellhole Cave & Batboy is an episode from True Creeps by Amanda Mednansky and Lindsey Charlick.

This episode is 01:04:51 long.

This episode was published on Mar 6, 2026.

Yes. Use the heart button on the episode page to add it to your favorite episodes list.

Yes. This page shows related episodes from True Creeps when more episodes are available from the podcast feed.