EP17 - 3 Disturbing Craigslist Encounters

The Scarecast - Scary Stories & Creepypasta by Michael Crutchfield

Jul 2, 202618:17Arts

3 ordinary Craigslist interactions that turned into pure nightmare fuel. In this episode of The Scarecast, we dive into three disturbing real-life cases where a simple online listing led to violence, manipulation, and mu...

Related Episodes

Continue listening to more episodes from The Scarecast - Scary Stories & Creepypasta.

7 Disturbing Disneyland Deaths

Sep 6, 2026 - 17:02

In this video, we explore 7 Disturbing Disneyland Deaths that occurred across some of the park’s most rec...

5 Killers Caught Years Later

Sep 4, 2026 - 23:51

Five criminals who believed they had escaped justice — some for more than 40 years — until preserved DNA,...

5 Scary Stories: Ghostly Granny, Sleep Paralysis, and Creepy Hotel Owner

Sep 2, 2026 - 31:59

Five true scary stories where the paranormal crosses paths with real-world danger. From a dead relative a...

EP26 - 6 TRUE Horror Stories Ouija Boards, Haunted Roads & Alien Encounters

Aug 17, 2026 - 33:51

Six creepy stories from people who experienced something they still can’t explain: a skeptic’s Ouija boar...

EP25 - 8 Disneyland Horror Stories

Aug 12, 2026 - 35:26

Could Disneyland’s magic take on a darker life after the gates close? This episode explores true chilling...

EP24 - 5 TRUE Scary Stories Hide & Go Seek, Neighbor Haunting & A Tinder Date From Hell

Aug 5, 2026 - 30:05

In today's episode, I'm telling you five creepy stories including a hide‑and‑seek encounter with somethin...

EP23 - 5 TRUE Scary Stories Disneyland, Ouija Board Sessions, and Strangers on AOL Messenger

Aug 3, 2026 - 35:01

In this episode, we're diving into five scary true stories submitted by listeners and pulled straight fro...

EP22 - 12 TRUE Scary Stories: Creepy Roommates, Children Who See Ghosts, and Almost Kidnapped

Jul 27, 2026 - 53:20

In this episode, we dive into a chilling collection of true paranormal and real-world horror stories: a p...