The Truth Is Out There (So Is the Deductible)

In this week’s episode, The Mystics blast off into one of the strangest close encounters in American history 🛸 Amber and Lesley head to Kelly, Kentucky in the 1950s to unpack the infamous Hopkinsville Goblin case, where the Sutton Family claimed their quiet farmhouse was suddenly under siege by a gang of glowing-eyed “little men” straight out of a sci-fi fever dream 👽 After hours of gunfire, terror, and holding down the fort, the family fled to the police who showed up to find a house full of bullet holes… and absolutely zero goblins. No footprints. No bodies. No proof. Just vibes. Unsettling vibes. 🔫🔫 Amber also shares the ongoing saga of the maybe-ghost “big sister” haunting her house 🥴 complete with a toddler who won’t stop chatting with her, mysterious jewelry-making sessions, and some truly unhinged baby monitor conversations. So was the Sutton farmhouse really attacked by aliens? Was it mass hysteria? Or did someone decide the fastest way to a home renovation was through an intergalactic insurance claim? 🤔🤔 The truth is out there… and so is the deductible. 👽🏚️✨ THE IMPORTANT LINKS AND CRED 📸 Cover Art by Rainbowfishdesign 🎶 The Grimm Mystics Theme Song by Bear Golden and Abby Golden The History Channel Cryptid Fandom - Hopkinsville Goblins Wikipedia Article from WKMS Courier & Press

You can listen to The Truth Is Out There (So Is the Deductible) online on Radio and Podcast. Open the player on this page to stream the available audio.

The Truth Is Out There (So Is the Deductible) is an episode from The Grimm Mystics by Amber Ringus & Lesley Gregg.

This episode is 44:04 long.

This episode was published on Jan 20, 2026.

Yes. Use the heart button on the episode page to add it to your favorite episodes list.

Yes. This page shows related episodes from The Grimm Mystics when more episodes are available from the podcast feed.