100,000 Texts, One Missing Gun & a Lesbian Bar

The Creep Dive by Tall Tales

Sep 29, 20261:07:47Society & Culture

This week on The Creep Dive, we're going extremely current. First, Sophie dives into the ongoing trial of former American Idol contestant and ex-pastor Caleb Flynn, who has pleaded not guilty to the murder of his wife, A...

Related Episodes

Continue listening to more episodes from The Creep Dive.

We’re Going Back to Cash

Sep 15, 2026 - 50:31

Can we just… turn AI off? This week, Jen takes Sophie and Cassie into the increasingly unsettling world o...

The Psychiatrist and the Nazi part 1

Sep 1, 2026 - 59:04

This week, Jen takes us inside the real story behind the Nuremberg trials and the strange psychological b...

The Lindsay Clancy Trial — Part Two

Aug 26, 2026 - 1:02:01

You asked (a lot 😂), so we’re releasing Part 2 on the main feed . A huge thank you to our Patreon Creeps...

What Happened in the Clancy House? The Lindsay Clancy Trial, Part One

Aug 18, 2026 - 58:45

Trigger warning: This episode contains detailed discussion of the deaths of children, suicide, self-harm...

Millions Stolen. One Woman Buried Alive.

Aug 4, 2026 - 1:01:02

This week on The Creep Dive, Cass brings the extraordinary story of Mary Carol McDonald a successful tele...

Doctor Satan

Jul 23, 2026 - 1:08:02

This week on The Creep Dive, we head from the eerie walls of an Irish holiday rental to Nazi-occupied Par...

The Great Stink (Don't Eat While Listening)

Jul 7, 2026 - 1:01:13

This week we're heading back to Victorian London, where the richest city on Earth was quietly drowning in...

Fake Bumps, Stolen Babies & Missing Diamonds

Jun 30, 2026 - 1:07:32

Trigger Warning: This episode contains discussion of graphic violence, fetal abduction, infant death, pre...