What If Jesus Is Just One More Myth? Inside a Homicide Detective's Spiritual Crime Scene

In this episode, cold-case homicide detective and Christian apologist J. Warner Wallace walks through the "spiritual crime scene" of his own journey from skeptical naturalist to follower of Jesus. Drawing on decades of investigative experience, he explains why the usual reasons people give for being Christians ("I was raised this way" or "I had an experience") are not uniquely Christian, and why the real question is whether the Gospels record what actually happened in the first century. You'll hear how eyewitness variation in the Gospel accounts first caught his attention, how the standard jury instructions for testing witnesses can be applied to the New Testament, and why abductive reasoning from four key facts about Jesus points most reasonably to the resurrection. J. Warner also unpacks his memorable distinction between "belief that" and "belief in," using a bulletproof vest story from an officer-involved shooting to show what genuine, evidence-based trust in Christ looks like when the stakes are life and death. Along the way, he addresses miracles in other world religions, the rising generational question "Is Christianity good and worth caring about?", and the power of God-honoring content to reshape our culture. If this conversation helped you think more clearly about Jesus, take a moment to

You can listen to What If Jesus Is Just One More Myth? Inside a Homicide Detective's Spiritual Crime Scene online on Radio and Podcast. Open the player on this page to stream the available audio.

What If Jesus Is Just One More Myth? Inside a Homicide Detective's Spiritual Crime Scene is an episode from The Cold-Case Christianity Podcast by ColdCaseChristianity.com.

This episode is 46:08 long.

This episode was published on Apr 29, 2026.

Yes. Use the heart button on the episode page to add it to your favorite episodes list.

Yes. This page shows related episodes from The Cold-Case Christianity Podcast when more episodes are available from the podcast feed.