You Two Scare Me Podcast at The Haunted Saint Hotel in Key West

In this episode of Talking Strange, host Aaron Sagers is back on the road. He visited Key West, Florida, and through a spooky fun and random coincidence, ended up connecting with local Ernest Hemingway House tour guide Amy Bebbington, who then introduced him to Andy Zyvith and Feliz Andrews of the You Two Scare Me podcast. Not one to miss out on the chance to chat about the paranormal, they sat for a chat at The Saint Hotel in Key West. The Saint was gracious enough to host everyone for the live recording in the supposedly haunted Room 106. In their chat, they discuss banshees from Bebbington’s Irish family, haunted Pittsburgh and a ghost that steals puzzle pieces, a Hat Man interaction and ghostly brothers, and of course, more about the ghosts of The Saint, and Haunted Key West. And of course, we chat about Robert The Doll and the books by David L. Sloan. Note: This was recorded way back in August 2025, and the file got lost along the way. Also, as this was an unplanned interview, excuse my rambling, lack of proper preparation, and a few stumbles. But it’s a great conversation. — Aaron. More about You Two Scare Me:Andi Zyvith and Feliz Andrews have been friends for over a decade, and have been wanting to start a spooky podcast together for just as long. They are two working moms who love to hang out, tell scary stories, and laugh their faces off. What better outlet is there for that than a podcast with your bestie? _______________________________________________________________ The Talking Strange Show with Aaron Sagers is a weekly paranormal pop culture show featuring celebrity and author interviews, as well as experts in all things strange and unexplained. Talking Strange is a creation of Aaron Sagers with production help from Michael Ahr. Host Aaron Sagers is a paranormal TV host and journalist who appears as host of 28 Days Haunted on Netflix, and on Paranormal Caught On Camera on Travel Channel, Discovery+, and MAX streaming service. If you like Talking Strange, please

You can listen to You Two Scare Me Podcast at The Haunted Saint Hotel in Key West online on Radio and Podcast. Open the player on this page to stream the available audio.

You Two Scare Me Podcast at The Haunted Saint Hotel in Key West is an episode from Talking Strange by Den of Geek.

This episode is 43:48 long.

This episode was published on Jan 16, 2026.

Yes. Use the heart button on the episode page to add it to your favorite episodes list.

Yes. This page shows related episodes from Talking Strange when more episodes are available from the podcast feed.