Phantom Island

Scary Stories To Tell On The Pod by Forever Dog

Sep 25, 202500:41:52Comedy

Anna and Andrew RETURN for High Spooky Season with a tale of haunting cartography and a tarot reading for our gentle listeners! - Credits & Links! Listener mail: scarystorypod@gmail.com Follow Andrew - @thatsajellyfish o...

Related Episodes

Continue listening to more episodes from Scary Stories To Tell On The Pod.

The Ghosts of “A Christmas Carol”

Dec 21, 2025 - 00:38:18

Anna and Andrew return for a ghostly Yuletide treat as they reflect on Dickens’ famed apparitions. - Cred...

A Halloween Treat

Oct 31, 2025 - 00:23:42

In honor of the spookiest day of all, Andrew reads the classic M.R. James ghost story "Lost Hearts." - Cr...

St Elmo and Dirty Annie

Oct 23, 2025 - 00:32:48

Anna and Andrew learn about an abandoned mining town and its legendary eccentric, then discuss hot people...

We Gotta Talk About Harold Again

Oct 16, 2025 - 00:29:38

Returning to their roots, Anna and Andrew once more crack open “Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark,” to re...

Orb in the Sears House (w/ Kelly Lyon)

Oct 12, 2025 - 00:49:21

Anna and Jason(?!) are joined by Emmy Award-winning editor Kelly Lyon, who tells the tale of her haunted...

Axe Murder House Reviews

Oct 2, 2025 - 00:50:24

Anna and Andrew share the chilling tale of a house haunted by an axe murdering ghost, and the subsequent...

Industrial Ghosts and Hotel Hat Men

May 7, 2025 - 00:52:18

Special guest Anna Thorup returns to weigh in on some reader submitted spooky tales! - Credits & Links! L...

Broken Mirrors and Elevator Accidents

May 1, 2025 - 00:29:50

Special guest Anna Thorup (Monster High) regales the pod with tales of her childhood ghost-hunting servic...