Bewitched By Classic TV & Finding Joy After Child Stardom with Erin Murphy

We welcome actress Erin Murphy, who spent her first eight years of life charming TV watchers as young Tabitha Stephens on Bewitched. Erin takes us behind the scenes at one of television’s most beloved classics, sharing vivid memories from a childhood spent witnessing the creation of Hollywood magic. Erin and her fraternal twin sister Diane were originally cast together to share the role of Tabitha, following child labor laws which severely limit the number of hours a toddler can spend working. But, as Erin reveals with a laugh, in the 1960s, rules were “suggestions.” Erin was the twin who took to the craft of acting and she was often brought right back to the set while producers pretended to swap her out. Soon, Erin became the show’s singular Tabitha. Erin recalls the delight of working with fantastical props, whimsical effects, and a cast she adored. A natural performer, she memorized not only her own lines but everyone else’s, and she truly cherishes her time on the set. Erin and Diane were treated with kindness and respect and were even given Donna Reed’s former dressing room where the amenities of home gave them space for play and nap time. Erin’s success on Bewitched soon led to appearances on other iconic shows, including Lassie. Erin is coming with “two Darrins” insights. She worked with Dick York and Dick Sargent for three years each and she shares a touching story about reconnecting with the original Darrin, Dick York, years later through the Kevin and Bean morning radio show. She weighs in on whether Bewitched can be read as a metaphor for being different or even being closeted and she opines on why the show still resonates today as a fun, campy, nostalgic, yet surprisingly modern-feeling classic. Erin also recalls the many rising stars who made early Bewitched appearances and she shares thoughts on why she never truly connected with Paul Lynde. She reflects on a groundbreaking episode, written by high-school students, that confronted racism. The story involves Tabitha and her best friend Lisa who is black. When told by an adult that they could never be sisters, Tabitha uses witchcraft to turn them both polka dotted. Erin identifies this as Elizabeth Montgomery’s favorite episode. After her early TV career, Erin enjoyed a normal childhood in Orange County before returning to the entertainment world as a host and reality-show participant in projects like Hulk Hogan’s Celebrity Wrestling and RuPaul’s Drag U. She went on to raise six children, including a son with autism, and has devoted herself to community service and volunteerism. Erin even launched her own alpaca farm, and turned it into a thriving business selling knit goods! This TV icon is as endearing as she is inspiring and Erin’s Hollywood and beyond journey is a testament to her grace, charm and character. In current media -- Weezy: One Shot With Ed Sheeran on Netflix Fritz: The American Revolution from Ken Burns Path Points of Interest: Erin Murphy on Facebook Erin Murphy on Instagram Erin Murphy on Wikipedia Erin Murphy on IMDB One Shot With Ed Sheeran on Netflix The American Revolution - PBS

You can listen to Bewitched By Classic TV & Finding Joy After Child Stardom with Erin Murphy online on Radio and Podcast. Open the player on this page to stream the available audio.

Bewitched By Classic TV & Finding Joy After Child Stardom with Erin Murphy is an episode from Media Path Podcast by Fritz Coleman & Louise Palanker.

This episode is 61:58 long.

This episode was published on Dec 4, 2025.

Yes. Use the heart button on the episode page to add it to your favorite episodes list.

Yes. This page shows related episodes from Media Path Podcast when more episodes are available from the podcast feed.