An Inside Job : The Caffey Family

Killer Instinct by Savannah Brymer & Studio71

Jun 17, 202655:05Society & Culture

Penny, Matthew, and Tyler Caffey were brutally murdered inside their own home. Terry Caffey survived five gunshots and escaped into the night. But when the only missing family member, 16-year-old Erin, turned up unharmed...

Related Episodes

Continue listening to more episodes from Killer Instinct.

SOLVED- Neighbor. Stalker. Killer. The Murder of Lauren Giddings

Sep 2, 2026 - 47:19

What first looked like the disappearance of a promising 27-year-old law school graduate soon became somet...

SOLVED- He Wanted His Mistress to Kill His Fiancée. She Refused. He Did It Himself

Aug 26, 2026 - 59:13

Kelsey Berreth vanished on Thanksgiving Day in 2018. What began as a missing-person investigation soon ex...

The Au Pair Affair Case

Aug 19, 2026 - 56:20

A quiet Virginia neighborhood became the scene of a strange double homicide involving a husband, his wife...

He Confessed to a Murder He Didn't Commit : The Angie Dodge Case

Aug 12, 2026 - 43:10

Nearly 25 years after the r-pe and murder of her daughter Angie, Carol Dodge's tireless pursuit of justic...

Blood Money - The Adelson Family's Plot to Kill Dan Markel

Aug 5, 2026 - 58:57

The conspiracy to kill Daniel Markel grew out of a bitter custody dispute, took years to solve, and ultim...

The Children's Book Murder- The Death of Eric Richins

Jul 29, 2026 - 51:02

In March 2022, Kouri Richins told police she found her husband, Eric, unconscious after serving him a Mos...

The Case of Janet Abaroa: Did Her Husband Get Away with Murder?

Jul 22, 2026 - 46:45

Janet Abaroa, a 25-year-old mother, was stabbed to death in her Durham home in 2005 while her infant son...

Six Years Apart. Same Beach. Was It the Same Killer?

Jul 15, 2026 - 44:44

Barbara Nantais in 1978 and Claire Hough in 1984, though separated by 6 years, were both found brutally m...