Goat Castle: Murder, Myth, and Jim Crow Justice in Natchez

In 2012, historian Karen Cox is digging through the Mississippi State Archives when an archivist tells her, “If you want to know about Natchez, you need to look at Goat Castle.” Cox expects a ghost story. What she finds is stranger and darker: a 1932 murder that turned into a national Southern Gothic spectacle. The victim was a reclusive former Southern belle. The suspects were her eccentric neighbors, a failed concert pianist and an aging socialite, living in a decaying mansion overrun with goats. Newspapers dubbed them the Wild Man and the Goat Woman, and tourists flocked to Natchez to gawk. But beneath the spectacle was the real tragedy: Emily Burns, a young Black woman forced into the story and ultimately blamed, while the white suspects became local celebrities. Sent to Mississippi’s brutal Parchman prison, Emily was erased from the public record. Cox set out to write her back in and to expose what Goat Castle reveals about justice in the Jim Crow South.

You can listen to Goat Castle: Murder, Myth, and Jim Crow Justice in Natchez online on Radio and Podcast. Open the player on this page to stream the available audio.

Goat Castle: Murder, Myth, and Jim Crow Justice in Natchez is an episode from Gone South by Audacy Podcasts.

This episode is 36:25 long.

This episode was published on Mar 11, 2026.

Yes. Use the heart button on the episode page to add it to your favorite episodes list.

Yes. This page shows related episodes from Gone South when more episodes are available from the podcast feed.